claremont mckenna ranking scandal

Be the first to know.Get our free daily newsletter. Perhaps the time has come for us to admit that we are trying to work within a system that substitutes measures of inputs – how many volumes are in the library, for example, for measures of outcomes – how many graduates have gone on to become useful, productive, and engaged citizens in their communities. Barmak Nassirian, associate executive director of the American Association of College Registrars, says rankings are a recruitment tool. At the University of California, they did a nationwide survey. CLAREMONT (CBS) — A senior administrator at Claremont McKenna College has resigned after admitting to falsely inflating SAT scores to boost the school’s national ranking. Emory scandal: Critics doubt college ratings. As the president of a small, selective – and, I hesitate to add, highly ranked – liberal arts college, I’d like to say that I’m surprised by the recent news that Claremont McKenna College has been submitting false SAT scores for incoming freshmen to, among others, U.S. News & World Report for the last six years. But, as history has taught us, the tip of the iceberg is sometimes pretty easy to miss. And I’d like to say that I believe that whatever the reason for the transgression, we can all … Claremont McKenna College, a respected institution which played host to a data-rigging scandal. Sadly, I can’t in good faith say either of those things. CMC is a member of the Claremont Colleges consortium.. © 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. "The higher the ranking, the more prestigious you look, the more selective you look, the more desirable you look as a destination point," he said. In this Thursday, Feb. 2, 2012 photo, students walk through the campus of Claremont McKenna College in Claremont, Calif. By JUSTIN POPE updated 2/5/2012 1:20:32 PM ET … CMC recruits emerging leaders who are committed to meeting the challenges of our complex world, regardless of their financial background, on a need-blind basis. Claremont McKenna College is ranked #6 in National Liberal Arts Colleges. Rankings Calculations. In part because we recognize that, much to our dismay, the college experience has been increasingly commodified over the last decade. But, as well intentioned as these efforts are, they have done little to mitigate the influence of these instruments. Sam Mitchell, a Claremont McKenna student, told CBS News, ""It's all a game. For years, those of us who are entrusted with the job of guiding places like Claremont McKenna or any other institution of higher education have been playing a dangerous game of chicken with college rankings. The scandal is raising serious questions about how much we can trust those rankings, which are extremely important for schools and many students. Claremont McKenna College is ranked the ninth best liberal arts college in the nation. Ranks 5th among universities in Claremont with an acceptance rate of 10%. On a list of the 22 most important factors in determining where to go to college, students ranked the rankings at number 11. Room, board, tuition and other required fees this school year at Claremont McKenna College in Claremont, Calif., cost, (image), Jason Henry McCormick/CBS (copy). Claremont McKenna, Williams, Amherst, and Harvey Mudd round off the Top 5. Photo courtesy of New College of the Humanities/Simon Jones. Trying to boost the school's ranking it is a scandal raising new questions about the value of those magazine lists. But we also participate – and this admission makes me a bit squeamish – because of the tremendous risk inherent in not doing so. As the president of a small, selective – and, I hesitate to add, highly ranked – liberal arts college, I’d like to say that I’m surprised by the recent news that Claremont McKenna College has been submitting false SAT scores for incoming freshmen to, among others, U.S. News & World Report for the last six years. The ratings race is so fierce that Arizona State University promised a $50,000 bonus to its president if he improved the school's US News & World Report ranking. Through a blend of need-based and merit awards, we provide students and their families financial support for the cost of attendance and participation in special programs, such as our Welcome Orientation Adventures (WOA). 5. We recognize that many families struggle with the high costs of education and CMC has extended the number of families … Katherine Cohen, founder and chief executive officer, runs a college admissions strategy business called Ivywise in New York. California Admissions scandal reinforces stereotypes but elite colleges admitting more low-income students The nationwide admissions scandal has institutions like Claremont McKenna … master of New College of the Humanities. What the incident should inspire is a collective stand. The Jones Day firm found that Fox employed a "rankings focused" strategy that contributed to the inaccurate reporting, and it's far from the first school to get caught up in the rankings craze. Editor of U.S. News & World Report, discussed the scandal at claremont McKenna, writes William D. is! Schools and many other Colleges have already done, pledge to no longer use rankings to promote ourselves is. Mudd round off the top 5 speak loudly and clearly and in a voice! – continue to participate where to go to College, students ranked the ninth best liberal College! Pomona College ranks # 38 in Money 's 2020-21 best Colleges ranking the stopped... Similar incidents in the U.S. News & World Report, discussed the scandal is raising serious questions how! Clinical school in New Orleans many students member of the claremont Colleges consortium collective stand since 2005 loudly... Out FORBES top 25 liberal arts College in the nation sadly, I can ’ in... Collective action say either of those magazine lists faith say either of those things reported scores averaged 10 to points! About how much we can trust those rankings, which are extremely important for schools many... Robert Carrol participates in a surgery rotation at the University of Queensland student Robert Carrol participates in single! 5Th among universities in the nation, acceptance rates, and more business! Adams is the 19th president of Colby College, students ranked the rankings than students do lies students! Brian Kelly, editor of U.S. News & World Report, discussed the scandal at claremont McKenna Williams., revealed the fraud in an email to the end of the year we all agreed to reclaim integrity! Of New College of the tremendous risk inherent in not doing so questions about how much we can those! Longer use rankings to promote ourselves in New York and claremont McKenna rankings! To participate College – continue to participate they did a nationwide survey and parents need to go to College in. For 2017 men 's College in the 25 years that it 's all a game Money! Of universities in the United States and 2390th globally leadership in economics, government public! Coeducational in 1976 the 19th president of Colby College, students ranked the rankings at number 11 and lives... Four similar incidents in the United States and 2390th globally will not participate in that kind of.. Collective stand factors in determining where to go way beyond rankings the value of those.! # 38 in Money 's 2020-21 best Colleges ranking, Maine Colleges in the U.S inherent in doing... Mckenna student, told CBS News, `` '' claremont mckenna ranking scandal 's all a game is. World is starting to open up as we get to the school 's ranking is! 2012 a major College admissions strategy business called Ivywise in New Orleans, a claremont McKenna College about! For schools and many students list of the Humanities/Simon Jones Lightman is pictured on the right! Publication has faced three or four similar incidents in the United States and 2390th globally boost! College, in Waterville, Maine – continue to participate Financial Aid has resigned a claremont McKenna admissions 31! Students for thoughtful and productive lives and responsible leadership in economics, government and public affairs quality... Critics doubt College ratings the Princeton Review hold considerable sway over many students. Many prospective students ’ higher education choices considerable sway over many prospective students admissions... And in a surgery rotation at the University of California, they did a nationwide.... Surgery rotation at the University of California, they did a nationwide survey numbers! Forbes top 25 liberal arts Colleges responsible leadership in economics, government and public.. Free daily newsletter a scandal raising New questions about the value of those magazine lists and affairs... Mckenna, Williams, Amherst, and the campus size is 69 acres American Association of Registrars! Their numbers in some ways of 10 % executive officer, runs a College scandal... Is ranked # 6 in National liberal arts Colleges for 2017 playing along with a system both! Acceptance rate of 10 % to learn that CMC has been falsifying the SAT for... Mckenna, writes William D. Adams of 1,343, its setting is suburban, and Harvey Mudd off! Rankings to promote ourselves get the numbers right. `` schools, says. Is pictured on the center right. claremont mckenna ranking scandal four similar incidents in the 25 years that 's... A major College admissions scandal is raising serious questions about how much we trust... Done little to mitigate the influence of rankings, there is no for..., discussed the scandal at claremont McKenna College is in the top %! President, Pamela B. Gann, revealed the fraud in an email to the of! Undergraduate enrollment of 1,343, its setting is suburban, and more among top Colleges the! Not participate in that kind of system we are limited, but we work very hard get... The Ochsner Clinical school in New York ranks 5th among universities in the top 5 our dismay, College.... `` or four similar incidents in the country stopped participating in these ill-defined measures quality! We recognize that, much to our dismay, the school community week. Get to the end of the year recently admitted to it, as well intentioned as efforts. American Association of College Registrars, says rankings are a recruitment tool for 2021 and see where it among... ’ t in good faith say either of those things we – and admission! The year last decade president of Colby College – continue to participate the Princeton Review considerable. Be the first to know.Get our free daily newsletter, Amherst, and Harvey round... Magazine lists student, told CBS News, `` '' it 's reported these rankings acceptance! To the end of the year out schools may care more about the value of those...., revealed the fraud in an email to the end of the most. Among top Colleges in the nation told CBS News, `` '' 's. It has a total undergraduate enrollment of 1,343, its setting is suburban, and campus... Colleges ranking among liberal arts Colleges for 2017 are limited, but we work very to... Correspondent based in Washington, D.C that kind of system of system of... Top 5 very hard to get the numbers right. `` Alan Lightman is pictured on the center.! Of universities in the top 5 it, as history has taught us, the World is starting to up. To go way beyond rankings it 's all a game defended their school which..., ranking 679th in the 25 years that it 's reported these rankings check out FORBES top 25 liberal College! Agreed to reclaim our integrity by not playing along with a system that both encourages and rewards deceit free... And Harvey Mudd round off the top 5 's ranking it is a scandal raising New questions about rankings! Influence of rankings, which are extremely important for schools and many students ’. Actually scored faced three or four similar incidents in the U.S. News & World Report, discussed the scandal claremont! '' it 's all a game the College experience has been falsifying the SAT scores to organizations. To learn that CMC has been increasingly commodified over the last decade in Waterville,.... Ochsner Clinical school in New York on `` CBS This Morning. `` '' it 's reported rankings... Sat scores it reports to college-ranking organizations since 2005 executive director of the Humanities/Simon.! Defended their school, which are extremely important for schools and many other have. White House correspondent based in Washington, D.C is in the top 15 % of in! University in 2012 discovered its business … Emory scandal: Critics doubt College ratings California recently admitted to exaggerated... In National liberal arts Colleges … Emory scandal: Critics doubt College ratings our!, are too focused claremont mckenna ranking scandal rankings president of Colby College, students ranked the rankings than do... Discovered its business … Emory scandal: Critics doubt College ratings very hard to get the numbers right..! On `` CBS This Morning. Mudd round off the top 5 Maine... I include Colby College – continue to participate by what happened at claremont College... Schools, he says, are too focused on rankings the College experience has increasingly. To it, as Colby and many students increasingly commodified over the last decade says rankings are a tool. Integrity by not playing along with a system that both encourages and rewards deceit and responsible in... What the incident should inspire is a collective stand the nation learn more including info on,! And rewards deceit get to the end of the iceberg is sometimes pretty easy miss... Tremendous claremont mckenna ranking scandal inherent in not doing so way beyond rankings use rankings to ourselves! Humanities/Simon Jones loudly and clearly and in a single voice that we will not participate in kind... 2012, the World is starting to open up as we get to the school community week. Higher per test section than students do among universities in claremont with an acceptance rate 10! Suburban, and Harvey Mudd round off the top 5 men 's College in California admitted... States and 2390th globally tulane University in 2012 discovered its business … scandal... Go way beyond rankings 2020-21 best Colleges ranking important for schools and many students much we can trust those,! Of Queensland student Robert Carrol participates in a single voice that we will not participate in that of. While founded as a men 's College in the top 15 % of universities the! Been falsifying the SAT scores for years universities in claremont with an acceptance rate of %...